See it work.
This is Sam's inbox on a Tuesday morning. Open an email to see what Mailyen does with it, and why. Then play both sides: the stranger, and Sam.

Now try it yourself.
A founder Sam has never been in touch with.
Asked for a stamp. A person Sam has never written to, who emails him directly.
Lisa's email waits outside Sam's inbox, and Lisa gets this reply, once:
Hi Lisa, Thanks for your email. I get more mail from people I haven't met than I can read, so yours is waiting outside my inbox for now. Nothing is lost. If it's worth my time, add a $5 stamp and it moves into my inbox, starred: mailyen.com/sam You get the $5 back as soon as I reply, even if my answer is no. If I don't reply within 5 days, it goes to Doctors Without Borders. If we've met and I'm just not recognizing this address, add the stamp anyway: you get it back the moment I answer. Sam Rivera (sent automatically by Mailyen)
What does Lisa do?
What Mailyen looked at
These headers, and nothing else. Never the message itself.
From: Lisa Park <lisa.park@brightpath.example> To: sam@northwind.example Subject: A question about your pricing API Date: Tue, 10 Nov 2026 10:40:00 -0500 Message-ID: <lisa@brightpath.example> Return-Path: <lisa.park@brightpath.example> Authentication-Results: mx.google.com; dkim=pass header.i=@brightpath.example header.s=s1; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=lisa.park@brightpath.example; dmarc=pass (p=NONE) header.from=brightpath.example
What it noticed: unknown-person, auth:pass
4 came in as always · 3 asked for a stamp · $0 released · $0 to charity
This is the real rule. The page runs the same code as Mailyen itself, here in your browser, on the same thing it sees in a real inbox: who wrote, to whom, and the subject. Never the message. Nothing you click here is sent anywhere.
One question decides it: has Sam ever written to this sender? Tick the box under an email and watch the answer change.
Want to check it on your own inbox first? On Free nobody is asked anything and nothing in your inbox is touched. Mailyen only lists the emails it would ask, so you can check every one.